DeGraw opened the Manhattan show with a few notable Christmas songs, pausing between tunes to tell the crowd that he’d “love to sing a Chanukah song, but I don’t know any. I only know the dreidel song. So instead, I’ll sing this” and then proceeded to play “I’ll Be Home For Christmas”. DeGraw shared his opinions on classic Christmas music versus more contemporary hits saying “new Christmas songs sucks and if you disagree with me you’re wrong” eliciting a laugh from his audience. He followed that thought up with “Elvis Presley released a Christmas song that tried to be sexy which is what Christmas songs should not be but if there was one that was going to be it would be this one” which led into “Santa Clause Is Back In Town”.